Romans 5:3-5 vs. “Blessings”

Laura Story · checked 2026-08-22

What we checked

PassageRomans 5:3-5 chapter ↗

Translation shownBSB (Berean Standard Bible)

Presents itself asinspired-by

Categorynot a quote

AlbumBlessings · 2011

Words addressed toGod, person unspecified

Teaching or experiencemixed

Graded against the standard

Quotation criteria not graded: this song never presents its words as scripture

Applies to every song the Name held holy · God shown holy · true of God · the standard

✓Reverent treatment

✓ What's good

Never says it is scripture, in any form: no reference, no verse framing, nothing presented as quotation
Its central move is a question rather than an assertion, so it never tells a particular sufferer what their particular suffering means
The premise it shares with Romans 5 is one the passage actually states, that suffering in a believing life produces something
It promises no reversal of circumstances and no healing on request, and the songwriter's own account describes a situation that was never resolved
Written by the sole credited writer out of a documented, ongoing hardship, which the interviews record in plain terms

⚠ Cautions

Romans 5 names four links in order, perseverance, character and hope among them, and the song names none of the middle terms
Paul's reason hope does not disappoint is in verse 5, the Spirit-given love of God. The song locates its comfort in nearness and in a home to come. Both are true elsewhere in scripture; neither is verse 5's answer
Paul grounds the rejoicing in knowledge, "because we know." The song's form is a question, and a question repeated often enough can settle into the general idea that hardship is good for you, which is not the passage's claim
The passages named alongside this song differ by source: Matthew 5 on the publisher-facing listing, James 1, Job 42, Hebrews 12 and Romans 5 across devotional write-ups. The pairing with Romans 5 is a reader's, not the song's

Verse Proof

Romans 5:3-5

The text in BSB (Berean Standard Bible)

“Not only that, but we also rejoice in our sufferings, because we know that suffering produces perseverance; perseverance, character; and character, hope. And hope does not disappoint us, because God has poured out His love into our hearts through the Holy Spirit, whom He has given us.”

Paul is writing to believers in Rome, and these verses come immediately after he finishes arguing that a person is justified by faith. Verses 1 and 2 list what follows from that: peace with God, access into grace, and rejoicing in the hope of God's glory. Then comes "not only that," and the sufferings in view are the ordinary pressures of a believing life in that city, not a single crisis. The rejoicing Paul describes is not a mood he is recommending. He says it rests on knowledge, "because we know," and what is known is a sequence that runs in one direction and stops at a named place. Verse 5 then gives the reason the last link holds, and the reason is not the suffering.

What the song says, described not quoted

The song opens with the things people ordinarily ask God for. Safety. Provision. Healing. A road with fewer obstacles on it. It then turns that list over and puts its central proposal as a run of open questions rather than statements: whether the good thing might have arrived in a form nobody would have chosen, whether tears are where the healing is happening, whether a sleepless night is evidence of nearness rather than absence. A later section names a longing that nothing available satisfies, and reads that ache as a sign that this world is not the singer's home. The last movement proposes that the hard things themselves may be kindnesses that were not recognised as kindnesses. God is addressed throughout as "You," and never named as Father, Son or Spirit. No verse is quoted, no reference is given, and nothing is framed as scripture.

What the song and the passage share is a premise: suffering in a believer's life is not wasted. What they do not share is the shape of the argument. Paul writes in the indicative and gives four links in order, suffering to perseverance to character to hope, and then names why the last one holds. The song writes in the interrogative and names none of the middle terms. It reaches for comfort at a different address: God's nearness in the night, and a home elsewhere that the ache points toward. Both of those are biblical. Neither is what verse 5 says holds hope up, which is God's own love poured into the heart by the Holy Spirit who has been given.

· Not a quote: The song quotes nothing and cites nothing, so the word-for-word standard does not apply. It shares Romans 5's premise that suffering is not wasted, and it stops before the passage's stated ground for hope.

▸ Official upload. Now listen with the proof in mind.

Paul's chain does not stop at "suffering is not wasted." It runs on to hope, and then names what holds hope up.

Why it matters

This is a song people reach for in the middle of a diagnosis, and the songwriter wrote it from inside one that has never resolved. That makes the gap between the song and the passage worth naming carefully rather than loudly, because nothing here is misrepresented. The song asks a question. Romans 5 makes a claim, and the claim goes further than the question does.

The distance matters for one practical reason. A question left open can be filled in with the nearest available idea, and the nearest available idea in most cultures is that hardship builds you. Paul says something narrower and sturdier. Suffering produces something in a person who has peace with God, the chain has an end, and the end holds because of a gift already given rather than because of the suffering.

Is it safe to dwell on?

Sung on repeat, this song moves between God and the singer.

People sing this in the middle of things that have not been fixed, and the repeat test has to take that setting seriously. What looping this song plants is the habit of holding a hard fact and a good God in the same sentence without dropping either one. That is a real thing to plant and a hard one, and a person who can do it in a hospital corridor has been formed by something. The dwelling tag is mixed because the words divide almost evenly. The praying and the aching are the singer's; the blessings, the healing and the kindnesses under discussion are God's, and God is addressed rather than described.

What repetition here does not plant is the rest of Paul's sentence. The song leaves you at the question, which is where it intends to leave you, and Romans 5:5 is the verse that answers it. If this one is on a loop, read verse 5 with it, and let the song do the asking while the passage does the answering.

Helpful comparison

Four sources put four different passages behind this song, and the divergence is itself the evidence. The licensing listing on Worship Together names Matthew 5. A NewReleaseToday devotional pairs the song with James 1:2-4 and prints Romans 5:3-5 alongside it. CCM Magazine's devotional reads it through Job 42:5 and quotes Romans 5:3-4. An independent lyric review works through Hebrews 12, Romans 5 and James 1 in turn. None of these is the song's own citation, because the song does not have one, and none of the sources checked here records Story naming a passage for it.

That is not a fault, but it does mean the passage a listener hears behind the song is supplied by the listener, and the four candidates do not say the same thing. Matthew 5 pronounces the poor and the mourning blessed and promises a specific reversal. James 1 tells believers to count trials joy and says what the testing produces. Romans 5 gives a chain and then names its ground. Job 42 is a man who has seen God and has stopped asking. A song that fits all four is not quoting any of them.

Sources

Laura Story — Blessings (official audio), laurastorymusicVEVO · (the recording checked for this proof; the artist's own VEVO channel)
Worship Together — Blessings · (writer credited as Laura Story alone; CCLI 5897818; the page's own "Scripture Reference" field names Matthew 5)
PraiseCharts — Blessings sheet music · (copyright line "© 2011 New Spring, Laura Stories (Admin. by Brentwood-Benson Music Publishing)"; writer Laura Story; album Blessings, 2011; no scripture reference listed)
Wikipedia — Blessings (Laura Story song) · (released 21 February 2011 on INO Records; 2012 Grammy for Best Contemporary Christian Music Song)
NewReleaseToday — Behind the Song: Blessings · (Story's own quoted words on judging God by circumstances or circumstances by God; the article prints James 1:2-4 and Romans 5:3-5 as its texts)
Guideposts — How Laura Story Found Blessings in Caregiving · (her account of Martin's brain tumour, the three-month hospitalisation, and the lasting vision and memory deficits)
CCM Magazine — Look at the Lyrics: Blessings · (a devotional reading of the song through Job 42:5 and Romans 5:3-4)
The Berean Test — Laura Story, Blessings · (an independent section-by-section lyric review, citing Hebrews 12, Romans 5 and James 1)

Corrections

No corrections to this proof yet.

Think we got something wrong? Tell us what and where, and we will check it against the text. Real errors get fixed here, dated, in public. Every correction on the site →